NATO learns as Ukraine's 'creativity' changes battlefield
text size

NATO learns as Ukraine's 'creativity' changes battlefield

Listen to this article
Play
Pause
Still from a drone video during Ukraine's 'Spider's Web' operation inside Russian territory.
Still from a drone video during Ukraine's 'Spider's Web' operation inside Russian territory.

BRUSSELS, Belgium - Ukraine's "creativity", including its massive "Spider's web" drone attack deep inside Russia, holds profound lessons for Western militaries, the top NATO commander overseeing battlefield innovation told AFP.

"What the Ukrainians did in Russia was a Trojan horse -- and the trojan horse was thousands of years ago," French Admiral Pierre Vandier, NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Transformation, said in an interview.

"Today, we see this kind of tactic being reinvented by technical and industrial creativity."

Vandier said the operation showed how crucial innovation and adaptation were for victory, as modern warfare changes at lightning speed.

"It was a real coup."

"We are entering a dynamic era where armies must rely on both major planning but also adaptive planning," the navy commander said.

"We will witness continuous innovation where, week by week, month by month or year by year, we will be able to invent things we hadn't anticipated."

- Need to act quickly -

Faced with the Russian threat, NATO this week adopted new objectives for its defence capabilities to ensure it will be able to repel Moscow.

But Western intelligence agencies have warned that the Kremlin is reconstituting its forces at a pace far outstripping NATO and could be ready to attack the alliance in as little as four years.

"Time is truly a crucial parameter. We must act quickly," Vandier said.

The admiral, who previously commanded France's flagship Charles De Gaulle aircraft carrier, said NATO needed to amass the forces to dissuade any adversary from trying an attack.

"When you say 'I'm defending myself', you have the weapons to defend. When you say you deter, you have the weapons to deter," he said.

"That's what should prevent war -- making the adversary think: "Tomorrow morning, I won't win."

NATO countries under pressure from US President Donald Trump are expected to agree a major increase in their defence spending target at a summit in The Hague this month.

That should see a dramatic surge in spending on military hardware.

But if cheap Ukrainian drones can inflict billions of dollars in damage on Russian bombers, is it still worth investing in vastly expensive systems?

"No-one in the military sphere will tell you that we can do without what we'll call traditional equipment," Vandier said.

"However, we are certain we need new equipment to complement it."

Officials say that over 70 percent of battlefield casualties in Ukraine are caused by drones.

But while drones are indispensable in modern warfare, they are not omnipotent.

"Today, you won't cross the Atlantic with a 10-metre-long drone. You won't easily locate submarines with such tools," Vandier said.

"If they accompany your large platforms, you'll be able to achieve much better results at much lower costs."

- Integrating new technologies -

The admiral, who works out of NATO's US base in Norfolk, Virginia, said the major challenge was "integrating new technologies and new combat methods, based on what we've witnessed in Ukraine".

NATO and Ukraine have established a centre in Poland designed to help the alliance learn lessons from Russia's invasion of its neighbour.

Artificial Intelligence and robotics are also increasingly having an impact and are set to help reshape the battlefield.

"All modern armies will have piloted and non-piloted capabilities," Vandier said.

"It's much more efficient to deliver ammunition with a ground robot than with a squad of soldiers who could face a 155-millimeter (six-inch) shell."

This transformation of military capabilities within the alliance, which NATO aims to expand by at least 30 percent over coming years, will come at a significant cost, estimated in hundreds of billions of euros.

Vandier insisted that while the financial effort was "substantial" it was "fully realistic".

"Today, we have all the tools. We have the engineering. We have the expertise. We have the technology. So, we need to get started," he said.

Do you like the content of this article?
COMMENT (22)
OSZAR »

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: unserialize(): Error at offset 0 of 216 bytes

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 92

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 92
Function: unserialize

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_city

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 100

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 100
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_region

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 101

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 101
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_regionCode

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 102

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 102
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_regionName

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 103

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 103
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_dmaCode

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 104

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 104
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_countryCode

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 105

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 105
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_countryName

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 106

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 106
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_continentCode

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 109

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 109
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_continentName

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 110

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 110
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_latitude

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 111

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 111
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_longitude

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 112

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 112
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_locationAccuracyRadius

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 113

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 113
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_timezone

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 114

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 114
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_currencyCode

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 115

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 115
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once

A PHP Error was encountered

Severity: Notice

Message: Undefined index: geoplugin_currencySymbol

Filename: libraries/Geoplugin.php

Line Number: 116

Backtrace:

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/libraries/Geoplugin.php
Line: 116
Function: _error_handler

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/models/Geo_m.php
Line: 46
Function: locate

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/application/hooks/log_forwarding.php
Line: 12
Function: get_geo

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/v3/index.php
Line: 404
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_v3.php
Line: 80
Function: require_once

File: /share/www/vhosts/bangkokpost/bangkokpost.com/index_bkp.php
Line: 147
Function: require_once